Lynn and I spent a decadent mid-week day on Shelter Island recently and had one of the best, most surprising lunches we have had in a long time. The cafe we usually frequent when we are on Shelter Island was closed which caused us to improvise and take a shot at dining at the Stars Cafe.
Particularly surprising was how busy the place was mid-week. There was a lot of take out, presumably to be transported to the pool or beach as a picnic. Despite the steady onslaught of patrons we were able to order quickly, find a seat and get served with admirable speed. The cause of this was an unusually efficient and mindful staff who kept the flow of business going.
Lynn had a Mahi-Mahi wrap that had generous portions of fish and I had the Mahi salad which had the same liberal amount of fish and was complemented by a considerable amount of
Unlike other favorite restaurants of ours, Stars has a menu that is impressive in its variety and depth. We look forward to trying other dishes there like the Avocado Chicken Salad, Carne Asada and Veggie Burger.